#1
|
||||
|
||||
Collings OM1C Vs Martin OM-28C Video comparison
Here is a brief video I made today comparing my Collings OM1C (Sitka/Mahogany) to a Martin OM-28 Custom Cutaway (Sitka/Rosewood).
The Martin is a 2017 build and has Adirondack Golden Era bracing and 1/4" braces. I'm not sure if that thickness is standard on OM28's. I am not sure what strings are on the Martin but they are new and sound really good. I'm gonna guess daddario based on my experience. .012-.053. The strings on the Collings are about 6 weeks old, Daddario EJ16 .012-.053. Your thoughts and opinions are welcome. No right or wrong here. Both are excellent guitars and even though they are from different builders, I think they depict the tones I would normally associate with their respective tone woods. I.e. Mahogany versus Rosewood.
__________________
Martin DC-18E (Ambertone) Martin HDC-28E Martin D-18 (2015) Collings D1 Traditional Collings OM1C Martin OM-28 Custom Cutaway Gibson EC Ebony Songwriter Custom Emerald X20 Emerald X30 Martin OMC-28 Custom Fender CS '63 Telecaster Custom Fender 61 Wildwood 10 Strat Collings I-35LCV Collings I-30LC www.heartsoulaz.com |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
They both sounded good, for some riffs the Mahogany seemed to sound better, for other, the Martin. I play a super shallow Lyrichord bowl of an Ovation Applause, Sitka Spruce top, Ovangkol neck & fretboard. It's gonna sound different in it's own voice just the same. Strings are D'Addario 12-53, tuned to Standard D.
|
#3
|
|||
|
|||
It is and I found the Martin far more pleasing and with more HD. What are your thoughts in terms of which one you like more?
|
#4
|
||||
|
||||
Quote:
Which do I like more? I have been a Collings fan boy for a long time and even owned an incredible OM1A several years ago. But I always wanted a cutaway. The OM1 I have now is absolutely stunning. I love the percussive midrange that is present but not overbearing. There is an overall sweet organic woodiness to the sound of a mahogany/sitka guitar that just rocks my world. So If I had to choose one, it would be the Collings OM1. But I just got this Martin OM-28 Custom cutaway yesterday and I need some time with it. I don't have a pickup in the Collings yet so the Martin OM-28 will see 5 gigs over the next 4 days in a row. (Doing a double header on Sunday) The OM-28 Custom has a Fishman Aura VT Enhance PU and I have to say it sounds really good. It's time for the Martin OM-28 to show me how it will do at my solo shows. I'll report back. Having played at home, I am encouraged. Here is an amplified demo I made at home. I think I had a little too much treble EQ on my amp and the EV Everse 8 Tweeter was aimed right at the Zoom Video cam mic. So the treble is a little sharper than it should be. Still, it sounds pretty impressive IMO through my Fishman Loudbox Artist/EV Everse 8 rig.
__________________
Martin DC-18E (Ambertone) Martin HDC-28E Martin D-18 (2015) Collings D1 Traditional Collings OM1C Martin OM-28 Custom Cutaway Gibson EC Ebony Songwriter Custom Emerald X20 Emerald X30 Martin OMC-28 Custom Fender CS '63 Telecaster Custom Fender 61 Wildwood 10 Strat Collings I-35LCV Collings I-30LC www.heartsoulaz.com |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Very cool, hope the audience is blown away by your playing which is no doubt enhanced by the guitars!
|
#6
|
||||
|
||||
Thanks for the kind words.
__________________
Martin DC-18E (Ambertone) Martin HDC-28E Martin D-18 (2015) Collings D1 Traditional Collings OM1C Martin OM-28 Custom Cutaway Gibson EC Ebony Songwriter Custom Emerald X20 Emerald X30 Martin OMC-28 Custom Fender CS '63 Telecaster Custom Fender 61 Wildwood 10 Strat Collings I-35LCV Collings I-30LC www.heartsoulaz.com |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
“Better" is definitely in the ear of the beholder.
I liked the warmth and blending of overtones on the Martin, but the mids are scooped as many EIR B/S guitars are. I liked the elevated midrange, presence, clarity and note separation of the Collings. As said in a previous post above, the riffs also sounded better to me on the Collings. Your overall take is mine. The Martin sounds like a classic Martin and the Collings sounds clean and pure and has more presence. The Martin has typical bass-bias and the Collings is more balanced across the tone registers. Some of the difference can be explained by the B&S woods. If a person was a singer who uses the guitar with few or no fills and riffs or solos, the Martin works. If the player plays lots of riffs, fills and solos, I would choose the Collings as it can do it all. You did not demonstrate them strumming, but I wager the Martin would shine at it. In your hands and playing style, the Collings is a seriously excellent tool. You have some great guitars and you are very worthy and deserving of them all with your musicality. I appreciate your work. |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Gary, I always enjoy your videos. If I had to choose one, I'd go with the Collings, but that's likely due to my personal preference for mahogany. The Martin sounds great as well, but the mid-scoop always kinda bums me a bit. Wonderful guitars, both, and your playing is excellent, as per usual!
__________________
Treenewt |
#9
|
||||
|
||||
Quote:
__________________
Martin DC-18E (Ambertone) Martin HDC-28E Martin D-18 (2015) Collings D1 Traditional Collings OM1C Martin OM-28 Custom Cutaway Gibson EC Ebony Songwriter Custom Emerald X20 Emerald X30 Martin OMC-28 Custom Fender CS '63 Telecaster Custom Fender 61 Wildwood 10 Strat Collings I-35LCV Collings I-30LC www.heartsoulaz.com |
#10
|
||||
|
||||
Great sounding OM’s…both of them. Choosing just one? I would also pick the Collings, but the Martin is no slouch.
The descriptions already used, are how I hear the two, with the Collings being more balanced and the Martin being more scooped. The mahogany vs rosewood stereotypes are very much in play, as well. For a pair of OMs, I think this is one heck of a pair!
__________________
Hope. Love. Music. Collings|Bourgeois |
#11
|
|||
|
|||
As you noted in the video, the comparison is as much if not more a comparison between mahogany and rosewood as it is between Collings and Martin. I have a personal preference for mahogany as a tonewood over rosewood (e.g., six mahogany dreadnought variants vs. three rosewood, etc.), and I find that guitars with mahogany backs and sides tend to record better than guitars with rosewood backs and sides (or said another way, the mahogany-backed guitars are more forgiving to mic placement, room treatment, etc.). Rosewood-backed guitars can often sound muddier in a recording than they do in person.
All that to say, I preferred the sound of the Collings, but the OMC-28 was no slouch. It definitely had more of that natural rosewood “reverb.” It’s interesting that Martin has made very few production OM-18s in their history. The longer scale than on a 000 really changes the character. I’m a big fan of the 000-18 as well, but I think the OM-18 is a nice bridge between the 000-18 and the D-18. |
#12
|
||||
|
||||
Nice video/review/comparison - thanks!
I'd be happy with either or both - which, as noted by others, really show off both the tone woods and (IMO) the characteristics of the brands. (FD - my only [2] guitars are a mahogany and rosewood OM, so maybe a little biased, though neither a Collings or Martin!)
__________________
"I know in the morning that it's gonna be good, when I stick out my elbows and they don't bump wood." - Bill Kirchen |
#13
|
||||
|
||||
Quote:
Thanks every one else for sharing your insight and thoughts. I agree this was as much a Mahogany versus Rosewood comparison as it is Collings OM (OM1C) versus Martin (OM-28C) I am still have a trial return period with the Martin and I do prefer the Collings. I will be gigging the Martin 4 more times over the next 3 days. ( have 4 gigs) No pickup in the Collings OM1 yet so it stays home for now. I gigged the Martin OM-28C last night but this was one of the loudest restaurant/bar venues I play. The crowd noise was almost giving me ear fatigue so it wasn't ideal to hear the Martin. Long story short, the Martin OM-28 sounds great but it is a bit lean and pristine for a loud room. My larger dreads got the job done better last night.
__________________
Martin DC-18E (Ambertone) Martin HDC-28E Martin D-18 (2015) Collings D1 Traditional Collings OM1C Martin OM-28 Custom Cutaway Gibson EC Ebony Songwriter Custom Emerald X20 Emerald X30 Martin OMC-28 Custom Fender CS '63 Telecaster Custom Fender 61 Wildwood 10 Strat Collings I-35LCV Collings I-30LC www.heartsoulaz.com |
#14
|
||||
|
||||
The Collings has the typical articulation that some love (I do) and others don’t care for. Add in the dry mahogany thing and you’ve got a guitar that will give what it gets.
I had an OM-28e-MD for awhile and found the onboard Aura to sound quite good but it does have a fair amount of sheen. I tended to roll off a bit above 5k with that guitar.
__________________
Beard Radio R Squareneck Hipshot | Collings OM1 JL (for sale) | Collings 002 14-fret | Collings I-30 LC | Anderson Raven Rob Allen, Fodera, Fender basses 2022-2023-2024 albums | nostatic site “Sometimes science is more art than science…” - Rick Sanchez |
#15
|
||||
|
||||
Quote:
__________________
Martin DC-18E (Ambertone) Martin HDC-28E Martin D-18 (2015) Collings D1 Traditional Collings OM1C Martin OM-28 Custom Cutaway Gibson EC Ebony Songwriter Custom Emerald X20 Emerald X30 Martin OMC-28 Custom Fender CS '63 Telecaster Custom Fender 61 Wildwood 10 Strat Collings I-35LCV Collings I-30LC www.heartsoulaz.com |