Best new larger bodied guitar under $2000

[jacot23]

Used D-18(though under $2K is getting hard to find) or new Blueridge BR140 or 140a

[L50EF15]

Let me add one from left field, because it’s not traditional: The Gibson G-200. I went looking for a large, solid wood flattop at the start of the year. I have a well loved Yamaha Eterna laminate dread (my first guitar, now 40 years old) and a couple of vintage Gibson archtops.

I was thinking D-15, D-18, D-16, or J-45/35/G-45, and I tried all of these except the G-45, and that because the stores (a couple of the NYC Guitar Centers) didn’t have any in stock. What they did have was the G-200. I tried it just for the heck of it and was blown away. I had read enough negative comments here that I didn’t expect much, but it is an amazingly good instrument. Balanced string to string, up and down the neck; but with a huge depth that none of my other guitars can match. And it doesn’t break up no matter how hard I pick it.

It really is like a big 000 or OM; in fact, it’s about the same depth. With the balance and power and bass response, I think of it as a flattop for archtop players (but then my favorite guitar IS my L-50, so I would say that). Anyway, it was also a great buy, because it was on sale at about $500 off the $1900 list price. Looking now, I see it back around $1900. I imagine that with the Memorial Day holiday approaching, there should be some sales and discounts going.

Try one. You might be pleasantly surprised.

[BlueBowman]

Originally Posted by Sarhog

Depending on your preference for top wood, I would look at a Taylor AD27 or AD17.

Taylor AD27e

This guitar responds really well to a light touch, as the OP is wanting. I think it's excellent for finger picking. (OP: I just bought and reviewed this guitar if you want more info. It's on page 2 of the general section.)

But there's been some other great suggestions in this thread: a good D-18 (used) or an Eastman E10D can be a nice choice if you find the right one. But for a "light touch" (very subjective), I think the Taylor above is a solid option.

[JMorse]

Originally Posted by lowrider

The Martin d-16 Special Rosewood that you get from GC or MF is going away the best guitar under $2000. And you can get 15% off just for asking.

I has the same materials and bracing as an HD-28. It just lacks the fancy trimmings. At around $1500, it's probably the best bargain of all guitars right now.

I played one recently and loved it. Getting ready to sell my beloved Gibson J15 so I can pick one up.

[tsmith28]

Originally Posted by lowrider

The Martin d-16 Special Rosewood that you get from GC or MF is going away the best guitar under $2000. And you can get 15% off just for asking.

I has the same materials and bracing as an HD-28. It just lacks the fancy trimmings. At around $1500, it's probably the best bargain of all guitars right now.

I agree 100%. You can't beat the Special 16 for under $2000 (and maybe even under $2500). I own a pair of Special 16's and recently owned two HD-28's, a D18, and a Gibson J45. The Special 16's play & sound the same or better, so I sold all those other guitars. The only reason why these aren't insanely popular is because they're GC/MF custom orders.

[Br1ck]

Originally Posted by Bob from Brooklyn

Are we saying a D18 is a slam dunk over a J45?

The aside from personal preferences makes it clear the poster likes the D 18 better.

It's like I'm inclined to state something like you can have a rich and resonate icon or a shrill and too bright soulless Taylor. Usually I bite my tongue, for one man's bright soulless is another's sonic nirvana. So forgive the inevitable bias we have formed for this or that. No puppies were harmed.

[BoneDigger]

I could recommend a few, but honestly, I think you need to look for a Yamaha FG5. It fits your requirements exactly.

[HillTone]

Originally Posted by Bob from Brooklyn

Are we saying a D18 is a slam dunk over a J45?

Yes. Of course it is. But both is best.

[View From Afar]

For half that you could get a Yamaha LJ-16. I bought one a few months ago and really like it, Sounds great both fingerstyle and picked

[boneuphtoner]

MAPP pricing for Larrivee D-03s are currently listed at $1883 new, and I see retailers frequently discounting these a bit beyond that - this is for a brand new guitar. This series of guitars, unlike the 40 series, feature Jean Larrivee's unique bracing that is designed for tonal balance - it is great for both fingerpicking and strumming. You can find used examples of this for several hundred dollars cheaper - these are such a steal for a made in the USA guitar that is at least the equal of Martin, Taylor and Gibson.

[12FanMan]

Play a $400 Yamaha FG-840-12 before you make your decision.

[Pickcity]

I would consider the Yamaha FG5, as already mentioned a time or two. I do not own one, but I am strongly considering one, and I have no need at all for another mahogany dread…Yet I’m still considering the FG5.

I can 100% recommend the Alvarez masterworks MD60. All solid wood (Sitka/mahogany), bone nut and saddle, herringbone trim, one piece mahogany neck. A great value for just under $1k. Incredible, really.

J45 > D18, any day.

[RiffRalf]

Originally Posted by Pickcity

I would consider the Yamaha FG5...

I can 100% recommend the Alvarez masterworks MD60. All solid wood (Sitka/mahogany), bone nut and saddle, herringbone trim, one piece mahogany neck. A great value for just under $1k. Incredible, really.
....

The MD60BG is so good I bought two! Both used for $400 from GC. I couldn't tell they were used, not a scratch on them.

I also want a FG5. (And that D16 MF/GC special that people mention)

For $2k you can buy a FG5 and a MD60

[SFCRetired]

If I was looking for a new guitar and had to stay under 2K and did not want RW, I would strongly consider the Yamaha ll series. If I wanted RW I would look at the GC D16 Martin that was mentioned. Not the D16E, different guitars. Not a fan of Chinese built guitars but I would also consider the Guild Chinese built guitar. I do think some of the LL Yamahas are built in China.

There are many more I have no experience with that are good. But If I'm spending 2K I want the very best I can get. I still think I would look hard at the Yamaha LL series.

I don't know the price but Larrivee makes great guitars and may have the best build quality out there.

[ShannonA]

If it has to be new, and you don't want rosewood, I'd go with a Martin D15m. If you can buy used, find a D18.