[TBman]

Originally Posted by Jimi2

Well, it would certainly be interest to a/b two guitars by the same builder, with the same top wood; seems like that would go a long way toward settling the debate about b&s. Would also solve my specific dilemma if I could play an O23 with an O25. What I was at least able to do today was play that O25 at the Emporium again today; and man, it’s quite a guitar. The amount of bass is amazing; as a fan fret tuned down to open c or open b I think it would sound incredible unless it’s just too boomy. I kind of suspect it would work though, and I had no concerns with it being too dark or muddy - it’s still got that clear, airy Lowdenness. I talked to the staff there, and they suggested that if I liked that guitar, that rosewood would probably be the best bet. I forget exactly what they suggested Walnut would contribute, other than less bass. But I think I’m pretty much decided.

I'm sure you will enjoy either one. Lowden makes a fine guitar.